Skip to Content
xtroverso
  • How it works
  • From €250
  • Scope
  • About
  • Knowledge
  • 0
  • 0
  • Nederlands English (US) Italiano Español
  • CLIENT AREA
xtroverso
  • 0
  • 0
    • How it works
    • From €250
    • Scope
    • About
    • Knowledge
  • Nederlands English (US) Italiano Español
  • CLIENT AREA
XTROVERSO
How it works From €250 Scope About Knowledge
NL EN IT ES
Client portal Let's meet ↗
Menu
How XTROVERSO works Your best sleep Why different Scope of work Framework and controls Verification Cultural manifesto FAQ About Work with us Press room Knowledge Contact Let's meet Client portal
NL EN IT ES
  • All Blogs
  • Ledger & Tax
  • Think You’re a Holding? Think Again: Dutch Court Slams ‘Certificate-Only’ BVs with Zero VAT Rights
  • Think You’re a Holding? Think Again: Dutch Court Slams ‘Certificate-Only’ BVs with Zero VAT Rights

    Practical XTROVERSO guidance on Think You’re a Holding? Think Again: Dutch Court Slams ‘Certificate-Only’: records, tax evidence, cash control, invoices, and.
    July 24, 2025 by
    Linda Pavan

    Why This Case Matters for Entrepreneurs

    Too often, founders and owners of micro and small companies set up a structure—think BV on top of BV, certificates instead of shares, management services done "gratis", without understanding what these moves mean in the eyes of the tax authorities. It feels smart, lean, and convenient, until the tax inspector knocks.

    The Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal just made that knock loud and clear: holding certificates is not enough to create a fiscal unit for VAT purposes. And if you're not charging for services, don’t expect to reclaim VAT. This isn’t just a technical ruling; it’s a structural warning to entrepreneurs who mistake ownership for entitlement.

    The Heart of the Case

    A private limited company (BV1) was set up to raise funds by issuing certificates. It used that money to acquire certificates in another BV (BV2) and provided it a loan. No management fee. No invoices. Just interest.

    BV1 then tried to form a fiscal VAT unit with BV2 and a third company. The tax inspector said: no way, and the court agreed. Why?

    Because:

    • Certificates ≠ control. Holding certificates without voting rights means you don’t hold the reins. You’re a passive investor.
    • Control = key for forming a VAT fiscal unit. If the hands that manage and the hands that profit aren’t the same, there's no “financial entanglement.” That’s a dealbreaker.
    • Free services don’t count. Management without invoicing? That’s not taxable. And if you’re not doing something taxable, you don’t get to deduct input VAT.

    The company also granted loans, which are VAT-exempt. So in 2018, it did... nothing that counts in VAT terms. No taxable services = no VAT refund.

    Three Hard Lessons for Small Business Owners

    1. Certificates are a financial instrument—not a control mechanism.
      If your holding structure is built on certificates alone, you're not "one entity" in the eyes of the tax office. You're just a fragmented cluster of liabilities.
    2. Free services cost you more than you think.
      Doing work for “free” inside your own group might feel flexible, but it kills your right to deduct VAT. If you don't charge, you can't reclaim.
    3. Tax strategy is not the same as business logic.
      Being economically clever doesn’t make your structure legally robust. Your fiscal unity must be visible, provable, and active. If it’s only paper-deep, it’s paper-thin.

    A Word from the Ledger

    At XTROVERSO, we don’t romanticize complexity. We translate it into consequences.

    This ruling confirms what we've been warning our clients about: compliance is not a formality, it's a filter. It separates what you think you're building from what actually stands when challenged.

    When you operate a micro or small business, your VAT recovery, cash planning, and group logic are deeply connected. There is no room for “implied control” or “intuitive service contribution.” Either your structure is clean, auditable, and billable, or it’s vulnerable.

    Final Thought

    If your company setup includes layered BVs, internal loans, unbilled services, or certificate holdings, stop. Before the inspector does.

    Ask yourself: Is your VAT strategy visible from the outside? Or are you assuming that what you meant to do will be enough?

    If you don’t know the answer, let’s talk. Because the tax office won’t wait for your intentions to catch up with your paperwork.

    Contact us

    AUTHOR : Linda Pavan

    Co-Founder of Xtroverso | Head of Ledger and Tax Compliance

    Linda Pavan brings disciplined precision to Xtroverso, anchoring its financial, fiscal, and operational integrity. As a ZENTRIQ™ Certified Auditor, she translates complexity into clarity—ensuring every decision is traceable, compliant, and strategically sound. Her quiet rigor empowers businesses to act with confidence and accountability.

    Linda Pavan | Head of Tax , Certified Zentriq Auditor


    Case Reference: Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal, June 3, 2025 — ECLI:NL:GHARL:2025:3429

    in Ledger & Tax
    # ES IT LEDGER & TAX Linda Pavan NL TAX
    Linda Pavan July 24, 2025
    Share this post

    Share

    Linda Pavan

    Certified ZENTRIQ™ Auditor and co-founder of XTROVERSO™, Linda brings decades of expertise in ledger management and tax compliance. 

    With a rigorous yet pragmatic approach, she ensures financial systems are not just accurate, but aligned with transparency, trust, and long-term resilience.

    BOOK A MEETING

    Linda Pavan

    Gecertificeerd ZENTRIQ™ Auditor en medeoprichter van XTROVERSO™, brengt Linda tientallen jaren expertise mee in ledgerbeheer en fiscale compliance.

    Met een rigoureuze maar pragmatische aanpak zorgt zij ervoor dat financiële systemen niet alleen accuraat zijn, maar ook in lijn liggen met transparantie, vertrouwen en veerkracht op lange termijn.

    BOOK A MEETING

    Laura De Troia

    Laura, con la sua empatia naturale e il suo forte senso del servizio, fa sì che ogni cliente si senta ascoltato, supportato e valorizzato. È impegnata a costruire relazioni durature e porta chiarezza, calore e coerenza in ogni interazione, contribuendo a rafforzare la fiducia e ad elevare l’esperienza del cliente.

    BOOK A MEETING

    Laura De Troia

    Laura, con su empatía natural y su fuerte vocación de servicio, hace que cada cliente se sienta escuchado, acompañado y valorado. Está comprometida con la construcción de relaciones duraderas y aporta claridad, calidez y coherencia en cada interacción, contribuyendo a fortalecer la confianza y a elevar la experiencia del cliente.

    BOOK A MEETING

    Aurelija

    Aurelija, turinti natūralią empatiją ir stiprų rūpinimosi klientu jausmą, pasirūpina, kad kiekvienas klientas jaustųsi išgirstas, palaikomas ir vertinamas. Ji yra atsidavusi ilgalaikių santykių kūrimui, o kiekvienam kontaktui suteikia aiškumo, šilumos ir nuoseklumo, taip stiprindama pasitikėjimą ir dar labiau gerindama kliento patirtį.

    BOOK A MEETING

    Tags
    ES IT LEDGER & TAX Linda Pavan NL TAX
    Our blogs
    • Ledger & Tax
    • Compliance
    • Market Pulse
    • Human Resources
    • Governance
    • Real Estate
    • I AM

    Read Next
    Your Co-Director Earns More? Congratulations, That’s Your New Salary Now.
    Practical XTROVERSO guidance on Your Co-Director Earns More? Congratulations, That’s Your New Salary Now.: records, tax evidence, cash control, invoices, and.
    XTROVERSO

    Artificial intelligence + human experience + professional oversight.

    Service

    How it works Your best sleep Scope of work Why different FAQ

    Framework

    Framework and controls Verification Cultural manifesto

    Practice

    About XTROVERSO Work with us Press room Contact Let's meet Client portal Pavan Geraedts ↗

    Legal

    Terms and conditions Privacy manifesto Cookie policy

    Responsible practice

    XTROVERSO

    Business administration for ZZP and VOF

    VAT period close and filing with Pavan Geraedts Adviseurs

    Office

    De Stuwdam 33-35

    3815 KM Amersfoort

    The Netherlands

    Meetings by appointment

    Contact

    +31 (0)85 401 9174

    hello@xtroverso.com

    KvK 70402787

    VAT NL858307790B01

    BECON 685811

    Professional boundary

    Administration by XTROVERSO

    VAT period close and filing by Pavan Geraedts Adviseurs (always included); further fiscal review where the package requires it

    XTROVERSO and Pavan Geraedts Adviseurs operate as coordinated practices. Responsibilities remain defined in the applicable package and engagement terms.

    © 2017–2026 XTROVERSO. All rights reserved.

    Website Logo

    Respecting your privacy is our priority.

    Allow the use of cookies from this website on this browser?

    We use cookies to provide improved experience on this website. You can learn more about our cookies and how we use them in our Cookie Policy.

    Allow all cookiesOnly allow essential cookies