Skip to Content

Why GDP Growth Is Bullsh*t if Jobs Are Shrinking and People Are Just Tired of Waiting

The Dutch economy posted a +0.4% GDP rise, on paper. But behind the revision lies consumer fatigue, statistical cosmetics, and a system pretending resilience while quietly bleeding trust.
June 25, 2025 by
Why GDP Growth Is Bullsh*t if Jobs Are Shrinking and People Are Just Tired of Waiting
Paolo Maria Pavan
| No comments yet

Let’s Start With the Boring Number: +0.4%

That’s the Dutch GDP growth in Q1 2025, according to CBS’s second estimate.

Yawn? No.

Because if you think that number is just a bland statistical revision, from +0.1% to +0.4%, you’ve already missed the real story.

GDP is like the temperature on a thermometer. It tells you the body is alive, yes, but not whether it’s fighting an infection, entering a burnout, or just put on a warm sweater. And the way CBS revises GDP over time? That’s not just housekeeping. It’s a symptom of something deeper: a statistical system struggling to read the behavioral pulse of a society that doesn’t play by old rules anymore.

The Why Behind the Upward Revision

The headline reads: “Growth mainly due to household consumption and trade balance.”

Translation? People bought more, exported more, and didn’t burn through their inventories as fast. But ask yourself:

Why now? Why not last quarter? Why so fragile?

  • Household consumption was sluggish a year ago. Fear, inflation fatigue, political noise.
  • Then, slowly, people started spending again, not because they became richer, but because they became tired of waiting.

This is not the return of confidence. This is resignation dressed as optimism.

When consumers start moving not because they feel secure, but because they can’t postpone anymore (the broken dishwasher, the overdue family trip, the neglected dentist appointment), we don’t call that economic momentum. We call it pent-up fragility.

Inventories and the Illusion of Health

Another cause for growth?

Inventories didn’t shrink as fast. A smaller reduction is being treated like a positive contribution.

But let’s be clear:

“Less depletion” is not “more production.” It just means we’re digesting the leftovers more slowly.

And if you're an entrepreneur, that translates into tighter margins, longer cash conversion cycles, and a silent battle between procurement and sales.

The Real Adjustments Are Not in the Numbers

CBS adjusted past quarters too.

  • Q1 2024 went from -0.1% to +0.1%.
  • Q3 2024 dropped from 0.8% to 0.6%.
  • Q4 2024 rose from 0.3% to 0.5%.

But these adjustments don’t just refine data—they reshape perception.

For policymakers, +0.1% vs. -0.1% is the difference between restraint and stimulus.

For boards, it’s the difference between tightening the belt and betting on growth.

This is how statistics influence strategy, not by being precise, but by setting the mood music.

2,000 Fewer Jobs. Still Think We’re Growing?

Jobs fell, again. Yes, less than the 14,000 initially feared, but still down by 2,000.

So while GDP rose, employment didn’t. That’s a red flag, not a footnote.

Because in healthy growth, jobs rise before output, not the other way around.

The fact that output rose while employment shrank means either:

  • Companies squeezed more out of less (which burns people), or
  • Growth came from sectors with low employment intensity (which hollows the middle class).

Both are unsustainable in a society already showing signs of compliance fatigue, identity confusion, and institutional mistrust.

What Entrepreneurs Should Really Be Reading

Forget the index. Look at the rhythm:

QuarterGDP (YoY % change)

Q1 2023

+1.1%

Q2 2023

-0.9%

Q3 2023

-1.5%

Q4 2023

-1.1%

Q1 2024

-0.3%

Q2 2024

+0.9%

Q3 2024

+1.7%

Q4 2024

+2.0%

Q1 2025

+2.2%

What you see here is not a steady climb. It’s a rebound after a mini-collapse.

It’s like a boxer getting up after a knockdown, not a sign of strength, but survival instinct. Yes, we’re seeing an upward arc. But it’s built on the ashes of an economic slippage that almost no one had the courage to name out loud.

XTROVERSO’s Take: Read Behavior, Not Just Indicators

At XTROVERSO™, we read the tension behind the trend.

We don’t just ask “What grew?” We ask:

  • Why now?
  • Who paid the price?
  • What risk did we just inherit to buy that growth?

This quarter’s GDP revision is a textbook case.

A growth in consumption powered by necessity, not confidence.

An export boost while geopolitical lines keep shifting.

A job decline camouflaged by index optimism.

This is not stable growth.

This is a system stalling on the runway, gunning the engine louder, hoping the noise will make people feel like we’re flying.

Final Word: Grow Ethically, Not Just Numerically

Growth must be understood not as a goal, but as a byproduct of clarity.

Of governance. Of accountability. Of trust.

At ZENTRIQ™, we don’t chase the GDP. We audit what it hides.

Because behind every +0.4% lies a decision someone made, rushed, ignored, or informed.

Our job is to expose that logic so CEOs, regulators, and entrepreneurs can lead from truth, not from trend.

AUTHOR : Paolo Maria Pavan

Co-Founder of Xtroverso | Head of Global GRC

Paolo Maria Pavan is the structural mind behind Xtroverso, blending compliance acumen with entrepreneurial foresight. He observes markets not as a trader, but as a reader of patterns—tracking behaviors, risks, and distortions to guide ethical transformation. His work challenges conventions and reframes governance as a force for clarity, trust, and evolution.

Share this post
Sign in to leave a comment